Review: The Pretty Dress Company Fatale Black Velvet Pencil Dress

[I purchased this dress under my real name with my own money. The Pretty Dress Company is not affiliated with this review, and all thoughts and opinions are my own.]

Sweet Nothings reviews The Pretty Dress Company Fatale Black Velvet Pencil Dress. Photo (c) Michi Rezin

Few things cause me more anxiety and/or not-super-great-body feelings than realizing I need to buy a special-occasion dress. Clothes are just a tremendous pain in the butt for me: I have to take big boobs, broad shoulders, long arms and legs, a shortish torso, and some fiber sensitivities into account, and while I’m often sized out of core or ‘misses’ sizes, plus sizes don’t always solve the problem. So when I realized I’d unexpectedly be attending a black tie dinner on Boxing Day this year (!), I was excited to spend a special evening with my family, but I had a mild private meltdown over the prospect of finding something to wear.

I visited a few brick-and-mortar shops and department stores in the city, but I encountered the usual problems: stores’ inventories stopped at a size 10 or 12, the only options in larger sizes were too short or didn’t suit me, I couldn’t zip anything past my ribcage, the price was prohibitive (which for me means it’s over $250, I know “expensive” means different things to different people), the only larger sizes felt too staid and mature, or the colors and fabrics didn’t look or feel good. I’ve gotten myself into trouble procrastinating on dress shopping before, so with about two weeks to go before the event I bit the bullet and ordered two dresses from a website that I’ve seen making the rounds on Instagram for the last year: The Pretty Dress Company, based in the United Kingdom. It does what it says on the tin: pretty dresses in pretty colors in classic shapes with meticulous construction. The site is easy to shop, but there was only one shipping option available to the US and it was unclear how fast it would be; it was also a whopping £31. It was £31 well spent, my friends, because it was OVERNIGHT shipping: I ordered the dresses late on a Sunday in NYC (early Monday in the UK), and they arrived around mid-day on Tuesday.

I ordered two dresses for choice, in different shapes and fabrics. I decided to stick with black for versatility, and I chose a “safe” style (the Thea, with its full skirt and simple stretch fabric) and a “riskier” (for me) style: the stretch Velvet Fatale Pencil dress. Stretch fabric pencil dresses, like the super-popular pinup styles from Pinup Girl Clothing or Stop Staring!, historically don’t suit me, and I think some velvets can dull people’s skin tones and pull luminosity from their faces. Nevertheless, velvet dresses seem to be on-trend this year, and I’m so glad I took the risk, because the Fatale velvet dress absolutely blew me away.

Sweet Nothings reviews The Pretty Dress Company Fatale Black Velvet Pencil Dress. Photo (c) Michi Rezin


The Fatale Pencil Dress is an off-the-shoulder fitted dress with a narrow skirt that stops below the knee. The body and sleeves are made of a super-soft velvet with generous stretch, and the bodice is lined with stretch viscose and the skirt with a smooth stretch poly fabric so that the dress comfortably hugs the figure. There is soft boning in the bodice (two pieces in front and two in back) to provide structure and support, and the sleeves are softly gathered with elastic to help them stay in position whether you’re broad or narrow-shouldered. It fastens up the back with a zipper. The bodice features a subtle surplice detail (cross-over or faux-wrap), and the neckline dips to a soft point in both front and back. The construction is impeccable, and the interior of the dress reveals careful, thoughtful seam placement and finishing to help both the bodice and the sleeves keep their shape and position.

Sweet Nothings reviews The Pretty Dress Company Fatale Black Velvet Pencil Dress. Photo (c) Michi Rezin


I’ve learned over the years that size charts are more like guidelines, because the sizes I wind up wearing match my measurements only about half the time. My bust measures slightly bigger than The Pretty Dress Company’s size 18, while my waist and hips measure slightly smaller. The Pretty Dress Company notes on their product pages that their garments run a bit smaller than the high street, so I was wary of sizing down to fit my waist. Knowing that I generally need a US 14 to fit my bust, I opted for the UK 18, and it’s a fantastic fit. The dress fastens comfortably even over my strapless bras (which tend to increase rather than minimize my bust measurements), and I’m glad it isn’t super tight over my belly and hips. I love that the length falls below my knees– I’ve tried on so many lovely dresses lately that just feel too, I don’t know, almost childish on me because they’re so short (waves at Pepperberry, today and always).

I am wearing shapewear in these photos– my Elomi Imogen waist cincher, which has since been discontinued, but it looks like the similar Kiki style could be a good alternative. I tried the dress on wearing my What Katie Did Mae corset underneath, but the corset felt too stiff and bulky for my liking; I prefer the lighter look and feel of the waist cincher for a long seated dinner. In these photos I’m wearing the Curvy Kate Luxe Strapless Bra in 34GG, but for the Boxing Day event I wound up wearing my Freya Deco strapless bra in 32GG, which isn’t as shallow as the Luxe and is therefore a better match for my shape (side note: the regular Deco bra doesn’t do it for me but the strapless Deco is the BEST strapless bra I’ve ever worn, and I’m very interested in trying the longline Pinup style from this season).

Sweet Nothings reviews The Pretty Dress Company Fatale Black Velvet Pencil Dress. Photo (c) Michi Rezin


Y’all, I couldn’t be happier this is the dress I picked for the dinner. I felt fantastic, both in terms of how I looked and in terms of how comfortable it was to wear. The fabric stretches beautifully– I never felt squeezed (even after four courses), and I could even take long comfortable strides in the fitted skirt and climb easily in and out of the car. I was worried my broad shoulders and the off-the-shoulder style sleeves wouldn’t play well together, but the elasticated gathered sleeves and stretch materials meant that I didn’t feel constricted (nor did it feel like the dress was ever going to fall down). Normally wearing a strapless bra means I’ll have to hoik my dress up all night, but once this dress was on and zipped I didn’t have to fuss with it again all night. I could have worn it for hours longer, gone dancing, you name it.

Sweet Nothings reviews The Pretty Dress Company Fatale Black Velvet Pencil Dress. Photo (c) Michi Rezin


I would like five more Fatale dresses, please, including some of the long glamorous gown versions, and don’t be stingy with the sequins.

*     *     *     *     *

DRESS: Fatale Black Velvet Pencil Dress by The Pretty Dress Company (£145, about $178 at today’s exchange rates), available in sizes 8-18 (UK). Velvet also available in forest green, midnight, magenta, red, and teal. You can see the full range of Fatale styles, including sequins! and tartan! and embroidery! here.

COCKTAIL RING AND COCKTAIL BAG: borrowed from She’s in Parties Vintage.

PHOTOS: Michi Rezin

18 Comments on Review: The Pretty Dress Company Fatale Black Velvet Pencil Dress

  1. Mom
    December 27, 2016 at 9:57 am (1 year ago)

    You were Incredibly glamorous last night. #NewYorkComesToRVA

    • Sweets
      December 27, 2016 at 10:06 pm (1 year ago)

      Thank you and I love you and I had fun celebrating with you :)

  2. Theresa
    December 27, 2016 at 3:23 pm (1 year ago)

    Awesome review! I really appreciate that you spent time describing the undergarments that you wore as I have always wanted to ask Immodesty Blaize what she wears under those strapless-style dresses. You look fantastic and the review was so detailed I now am more motivated to try this company whose dresses I have been keeping an eye on for the last couple of years.

    • Sweets
      December 27, 2016 at 9:41 pm (1 year ago)

      Thanks so much, Theresa, I’m so glad it was helpful! I definitely want to try more dresses in the future after my great experience with this one :)

  3. S.B
    December 27, 2016 at 3:27 pm (1 year ago)

    You look absolutely stunning in that dress!

    • Sweets
      December 27, 2016 at 10:05 pm (1 year ago)

      Thank you! :)

  4. Ash
    December 27, 2016 at 3:30 pm (1 year ago)

    omg this looks so amazing on you!!! Your photos do it way more justice than the ones on the website; it looks like it was made for you. I won’t need a fancy dress like this for another year or so but goddamn I want to snap this up right now.

    • Sweets
      December 27, 2016 at 10:03 pm (1 year ago)

      Thank you Ash! I’m so happy with it I kind of want to wear it even when fancy dresses aren’t remotely appropriate

  5. Jill
    December 27, 2016 at 11:38 pm (1 year ago)

    WOW! You are gorgeous beyond words in this dress! I always share your blog posts and photos with my teen daughter, can’t WAIT to show her this look!

  6. Rare.Device
    December 28, 2016 at 1:23 am (1 year ago)

    Oh my godddd, you look stunning. I’m not even as tall as you, but I feel you on the too-short hems; I hope just-below-the-knee length like this continues to come back in fashion.

  7. Kate
    December 28, 2016 at 11:50 am (1 year ago)

    Can you please let us know how tall you are? I have been interested in this company for months now and your review is so positive – thank you.

    • Sweets
      December 28, 2016 at 4:40 pm (1 year ago)

      Hi Kate, no problem! I’m 5’10”, and I’m short-waisted with longer legs. Hope that helps! Give a shout if you need any other info :)

  8. Contrary Kiwi
    January 8, 2017 at 11:31 pm (1 year ago)

    I think this dress suits your body shape fantastically and your shoulders look amazing.

  9. astrid
    January 11, 2017 at 6:32 am (1 year ago)

    Awesome review. You look stunning and I also love your hair and make-up here. Your lipstick is ALWAYS on point!

  10. Rebecca Levine
    February 13, 2017 at 4:55 pm (1 year ago)

    I’m looking at buying this, and I’m a 34HH with a 33″ waist and 44″ hips, so I’m between ordering an 18 or 20. I saw you went with the 18 for GG cups… do you think 18 would work for me, or should I go 20 and tailor the dress?


    • Sweets
      February 16, 2017 at 3:43 pm (1 year ago)

      Hi Rebecca! If you’re based in the US, I say go for the 20 and tailor it. Overseas shipping is super, super expensive (returning the dress I didn’t keep cost me around $65), and in those instances I always prefer to be safe than sorry. I hope that helps!

  11. Megan
    March 16, 2017 at 4:05 pm (1 year ago)

    The dress looks lovely on you. I had found the PDC from another blogger and ordered a Hourglass Dress. I chose a 10 because while my bust is larger, my hips and waist were smaller than what they said the 10 should fit. Well, it fits totally opposite! I’m a DD and the top was gaping. The bottom, however, was almost too tight. I contacted them and they never bothered to respond. They have beautiful pieces but their sizing is messed up and they have no customer service :/

    • Sweets
      March 16, 2017 at 4:50 pm (1 year ago)

      Oh no! I’m sorry to hear that. I’d definitely try reaching out again– they should try to make it right for you.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>